Skip to main content

Recruitment models

Recruitment fee models compared

How startups pay for hiring: contingent, retained, embedded, subscription, in-house and monthly models compared on cash timing, leaver risk and fit.

In short

There are six common ways to pay for hiring: contingent fees, retained search, embedded recruiters, subscription recruitment, an in-house team, and monthly salary-linked models like SUS. They differ mainly in when you pay, who carries the risk if a hire does not work out, and how much of the process you run yourself. None of them is cheapest in every case — the right one depends on hiring volume, seniority, how long the hire stays and how much cash you can release at the point of hire.

Key facts

Contingent
Pay on placement, one large fee
Retained
Staged payments, usually senior or scarce roles
Embedded
Day or monthly rate for recruiter capacity
Subscription
Recurring fee for ongoing recruiting capacity
In-house
Fixed salary cost, best at sustained volume
Monthly (Startup Staffing)
Monthly percentage of salary while the hire stays

The models side by side

Read down the cash timing column first — it is usually the deciding factor.

Comparison of recruitment fee models
ModelWhen you payRisk if the hire leavesBest fit
ContingentOne fee on start dateShort rebate window, then the fee is spentOccasional hires with cash available
RetainedStaged: engagement, shortlist, placementUsually re-run rather than refundSenior, confidential or very scarce roles
EmbeddedDay or monthly rate while engagedYou carry it — you paid for time, not outcomeSustained hiring bursts without in-house capacity
Fixed instalmentsA fixed one-off fee split into a set number of monthly payments, then it endsSet by the agency's own termsCompared in full with the monthly model on the Startup Staffing vs traditional recruitment fees page, linked under Tools that follow from this guide
SubscriptionA recurring fee while the subscription runs, whether or not a hire is made that monthYou carry it — the fee buys capacity, not a particular hireSeveral roles open at once over a planned period
In-houseSalary, every month regardless of hiresYou carry it entirelyHigh, steady hiring volume
Monthly (Startup Staffing)Monthly percentage of gross salary while employedBilling stops when employment endsStartups protecting cash at the point of hire

Fixed instalments and SUS are different instruments: an instalment plan ends once the fixed fee is paid, while a SUS fee follows one employee's salary for as long as they stay. The Startup Staffing vs traditional recruitment fees page, linked at the foot of this guide, compares the two in full.

What actually differs

Every model pays for the same underlying work: finding, assessing and closing a candidate. What changes is the shape of the payment and where the risk sits when things do not go to plan.

A contingent fee concentrates the cost into one month and puts almost all of the tenure risk on the buyer. An in-house team spreads cost evenly but you pay it whether or not roles are open. A subscription works the same way for an outside team: you pay for capacity over a period, so it suits a steady run of roles and wastes money in a quiet month. A monthly model links the payment to the employment continuing, which spreads the cost and shares the tenure risk — but it also means the total keeps accruing while the person stays.

One hire, two fee shapes, month by month

An illustrative example, not a quote: one hire on £60,000, comparing a 20% one-off fee with a 17.5% monthly SUS fee on gross monthly salary. Both percentages are the illustrative figures used in the rate calculator.

Cumulative recruitment fee paid for one illustrative hire: a one-off fee compared with Startup Staffing's monthly fee
Months employedOne-off fee paid so farStartup Staffing fees so far
1£12,000£875
6£12,000£5,250
12£12,000£10,500
14£12,000£12,250
18£12,000£15,750
24£12,000£21,000

The one-off fee is £12,000 on the start date. The SUS fee is £875 a month while the person stays. £12,000 ÷ £875 is about 13.7 months, so from month 14 the SUS total is higher than the one-off fee, and it keeps rising for as long as the employment continues. That is the trade for paying nothing up front and nothing once the person leaves.

Who pays the recruitment fee

The hiring company does. In Great Britain, section 6(1)(a) of the Employment Agencies Act 1973 says an employment agency must not request or receive a fee from a person for finding them work, except in circumstances set out in regulations. Regulation 26 of the Conduct of Employment Agencies and Employment Businesses Regulations 2003 lists those exceptions, which are narrow and occupation-specific. This is general information, not legal advice.

In practice that means the fee models on this page are all paid by the employer. If a recruiter asks a candidate to pay for being put forward for a role, that is worth questioning.

Questions that decide the model for you

  1. How many hires will you genuinely make in the next twelve months?
  2. Can you release a five-figure fee in the same month as a new salary, more than once?
  3. How specialist is the role — could an in-house generalist recruiter fill it?
  4. How much founder and engineering time can you spend on search itself?
  5. What happens to your plan if one of the first three hires leaves within a year?
  6. If the hire stays three years, which model has cost the most by then — and does that still matter to you?

Common questions

Is a monthly recruitment fee a form of finance?
No. Nothing is lent, there is no interest and there is no credit agreement. It is a recruitment fee structured as monthly payments linked to a specific employee, which stop if that employment ends.
What is subscription recruitment?
A recurring fee, usually monthly, for ongoing recruiting capacity from an outside team, often covering several roles at once. You pay while the subscription runs whether or not a hire is made in a given month. It is not the same as SUS, where each fee is tied to one employee's salary and stops when that employment ends.
Can a recruitment agency charge the candidate instead of the employer?
In Great Britain, generally not. Section 6(1)(a) of the Employment Agencies Act 1973 stops an agency requesting or receiving a fee from someone for finding them work, apart from narrow exceptions in regulation 26 of the 2003 Conduct Regulations. The employer pays. This is general information, not legal advice.
When is retained search the better answer?
When the role is senior, confidential, or so scarce that a search needs firm commitment on both sides. Retained works because both parties commit up front — which is exactly why it does not suit a startup trying to protect cash.
At what point does an in-house recruiter make sense?
When hiring is continuous rather than episodic. If roles will be open every month for the next year, a salaried recruiter usually wins on cost per hire; if hiring is lumpy, you pay for the gaps.

Sources

Where a fact in this guide comes from a document you can check yourself, it is listed here. We do not cite market statistics or benchmark data we have not published.

Model the cost of a hire

Put a salary in and see the illustrative monthly figure, the cumulative cost and the crossover point against a traditional fee.

Open the rate calculator

Any percentages or figures shown in this article are illustrative examples used to explain the model. They are not quoted rates, market benchmarks or salary data.