Compare the models
Startup Staffing vs traditional recruitment fees
Both models pay for the same work: finding, assessing and introducing someone you go on to employ. They differ in when the money leaves your business, and in what happens if that person does not stay.
Startup Staffing is not automatically cheaper. It changes when you pay: an agreed monthly percentage while the hire stays, instead of one fee at the start. Until the crossover, the cumulative total stays below the one-off fee; after it, the total is higher and keeps rising. At this page's example figures, month 14 is the first full month above. See the trade-off in full
Side by side
Example figures use a £60,000 salary, a 20% traditional fee and a 17.5% SUS monthly fee. They are illustrative only, not a quotation.
When you pay
- Traditional
- A single fee invoiced at the point of hire, usually payable within days of the start date.
- Startup Staffing
- An agreed percentage of gross monthly salary, invoiced each month while that employee remains employed.
Cash in month one
- Traditional
- £12,000 on a £60,000 salary at 20%.
- Startup Staffing
- £875 on the same salary at 17.5% of gross monthly salary.
If the employee leaves
- Traditional
- Typically a rebate on a sliding scale within a limited window, then nothing.
- Startup Staffing
- Billing for that employee stops from their final date of employment. There is nothing left to recover.
Total cost over a long tenure
- Traditional
- Fixed and closed off on day one.
- Startup Staffing
- Continues while the employee stays: at these example figures, month 14 is the first full month above the traditional fee (exact breakeven about 13.7 months), and it keeps rising after that.
Flexibility later
- Traditional
- None needed — the cost is already settled.
- Startup Staffing
- The buy-out value, or the basis for calculating it, is agreed with you in writing in your commercial terms at the outset, for each hire. You can exercise that pre-agreed option later under those terms, without a fresh commercial negotiation. Once it is paid, future monthly billing for that hire stops. Other hires are unaffected.
Who employs the person
- Traditional
- You do.
- Startup Staffing
- You do. SUS is a payment model for permanent recruitment, not an employer of record or umbrella arrangement.
Recruitment work involved
- Traditional
- Search, assessment, introduction, offer management.
- Startup Staffing
- Identical. The delivery is the same permanent recruitment process — only the way the fee is paid changes.
When traditional makes more sense
- You have the cash available and want the recruitment cost closed off on day one.
- You are hiring one senior person and expect a very long tenure.
- Your finance team would rather carry a single known cost than a monthly commitment.
When Startup Staffing makes more sense
- Working capital is tight and a large fee at the point of hire is painful.
- You are building a team, where several fees would land in the same month.
- You want the recruitment cost to track whether the hire actually stays, rather than the introduction alone.
Three ways a recruitment fee can be structured
A one-off fee is not the only alternative to SUS. Some recruiters let you pay the fee monthly instead: they spread the cost of a fixed total fee over a capped number of monthly instalments, and the payments end once that fee is paid. All three are described here as categories, not as named suppliers or quoted rates.
Shape of the fee
- One-off fee
- A single percentage of first-year salary, invoiced once at the point of hire.
- Capped monthly plan
- A fixed total fee you pay monthly, spread over a set number of instalments, usually twelve, then it ends.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- An agreed percentage of gross monthly salary, invoiced monthly while that employee remains employed.
Cash at the point of hire
- One-off fee
- The largest single outflow of the three, close to the start date.
- Capped monthly plan
- One instalment, not the whole fee.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- One monthly fee, not the whole fee.
Total cost if the hire stays a long time
- One-off fee
- Fixed and closed off on day one.
- Capped monthly plan
- Fixed once the instalment term completes.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- Keeps rising while the employment continues, so it can end up higher than either of the others.
If the employee leaves early
- One-off fee
- The fee is already paid; recovery depends on the rebate clause in that agency's terms.
- Capped monthly plan
- Depends on the contract. Some plans continue to fall due for the remaining instalments even after the person has gone — ask.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- Billing for that employee stops from their final date of employment.
When the supplier has finished earning
- One-off fee
- At the introduction.
- Capped monthly plan
- At the end of the fixed instalment term.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- Never in advance: the fee stays aligned with the hire staying in role.
Route to stop future charges
- One-off fee
- Not applicable — nothing further is due.
- Capped monthly plan
- Not usually applicable; the instalment schedule runs to its end.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- The buy-out value, or the basis for calculating it, is agreed with you in writing in your commercial terms at the outset, for each hire.
Who employs the person
- One-off fee
- You do.
- Capped monthly plan
- You do.
- Startup Staffing monthly fee
- You do. SUS is a payment model for permanent recruitment, not an employer of record or umbrella arrangement.
Cash-flow timing, not a lower total
The strongest argument for SUS is against a large one-off fee at the point of hire: it smooths recruitment cost across the months a hire is actually with you and keeps more cash in the business early on, which matters when you are protecting runway. That is timing and smoothing. It is not a claim of lower total cost — over a long, successful tenure SUS can cost more than a one-off fee.
Against a capped monthly plan, compare the actual figures
We do not claim SUS always gives better cash flow than a capped plan. If a capped twelve-month plan charges the same percentage of salary as SUS, spread equally, the monthly payment and the cumulative cost are identical through month 12. The structural difference begins in month 13: the capped plan has finished, and the SUS fee continues while the employee remains employed.
A pre-agreed route to close out future charges
The buy-out value, or the basis for calculating it, is agreed with you in writing in your commercial terms at the outset, for each hire. You can exercise that pre-agreed option later under those terms, without a fresh commercial negotiation. Once it is paid, future monthly billing for that hire stops. Other hires are unaffected. Monthly fees already paid are not deducted, credited or refunded against the buy-out by default; they cover the months already elapsed. It is a route to close out future monthly charges for one hire, not a cap on what recruitment can cost.
Being straight about the trade-off
SUS changes when recruitment expenditure happens. Payments continue while each hire remains employed under the agreed terms, so the cumulative total can pass a conventional one-off fee: at the example figures above, Month 14 is the first full month where cumulative Startup Staffing cost is above the one-off fee. The exact breakeven is about 13.7 months. The calculator shows both figures openly rather than hiding them, and your written terms already contain the buy-out you can exercise to stop future monthly charges for a hire.
At the example figures a single £60,000 hire is £12,000 traditionally, or £875 per month under SUS — £13,125 cumulatively across 15 months. Illustrative only, not a quotation.
Keep reading
- The Startup Staffing explainerThe commercial model on one printable page: what you are agreeing to, and questions to ask any recruiter.
- For foundersHiring while protecting working capital.
- For finance leadsCash timing, cumulative cost and crossover.
- For people teamsExternal hiring support alongside your team.
- Full FAQCosts, contracts, buy-outs and getting started.
- Cost calculatorModel one role or a whole hiring plan.
Want this compared against your own numbers?
Send us the roles and rough salaries you are planning and we will talk you through how the two models land for your business.
- A specific live vacancy you are trying to fill
- Hiring you are planning over the next few months
- Several future hires and how they would work together
- Whether SUS is the right fit for your business at all
Prefer to talk? 01865 657 000
Prefer email? hello@startup-staffing.com